Inhibition of enzymatic activities of Bothrops asper snake venom and docking analysis of compounds from plants used in Central America to treat snakebite envenoming.

ETHNOPHARMACOLOGICAL RELEVANCE: Snakebite envenoming is a public health problem of high impact in Central America. Bothrops asper, known as barba amarilla, terciopelo, and equis, is the snake species responsible for most snakebites in Central America. In this region, there is a long-standing tradition on the use of plants in the management of snakebites, especially in indigenous communities. Ethnomedical use of Eryngium foetidum L., Neurolaena lobata (L.) Cass. and Pimenta dioica (L.) Merr. to treat snakebite envenoming has been reported in Belice, Guatemala, Nicaragua, and Costa Rica. Extracts of the leaves of these plants have shown anti-venom activities in in vitro assays in previous studies. AIM OF THE STUDY: To assess the ability of organic fractions from these three plants to inhibit enzymatic activities associated with toxicity of the venom of B. asper, and to study, by docking analysis, the interaction of metalloproteinase and phospholipases A2 (PLA2) from B. asper venom with secondary metabolites previously described in these plants. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Organic fractions were obtained from these three plant species and their ability to neutralize proteolytic, PLA2 and in vitro coagulant activities of B. asper venom was assessed. A phytochemical analysis was carried out in these fractions. The interaction of secondary metabolites previously described in these plants with three toxins from B. asper venom (a metalloproteinase, a PLA2 and a PLA2 homologue) was investigated by docking analysis. RESULTS: The inhibitory activity of plants was mainly concentrated in their polar fractions. Acetonic fraction from P. dioica was the most active against PLA2 activity, while the acetonic fraction of E. foetidum completely inhibited the proteolytic activity of the venom. Coagulant activity was partially inhibited only by the acetone and ethyl acetate fractions of P. dioica. Phytochemical analysis of the most bioactive fractions identified flavonoids, saponins, essential oils, coumarins, alkaloids, tannins and sesquiterpene lactones. Docking analysis revealed high affinity interactions of several secondary metabolites of these plants with residues in the vicinity of the catalytic site of these enzymes and, in the case of PLA2 homologue myotoxin II, in the hydrophobic channel. CONCLUSIONS: Various fractions from these plants have inhibitory activity against enzymatic actions of B. asper venom which are directly associated with toxicological effects. Docking analysis showed structural evidence of the interaction of secondary metabolites with three toxins. These observations provide support to the potential of these plants to inhibit relevant toxic components of this snake venom.

Neutralization of toxic activities of Bothrops asper snake venom by ethnomedicinal plants used in Central America, with emphasis in Guatemala: a review / Neutralización de actividades tóxicas del veneno de la serpiente Bothrops asper por plantas etnomedicinales utilizadas en Centroamérica, con énfasis en Guatemala: Revisión

There are few scientific studies that explore the use of medicinal plants for snakebite envenoming in Central America, although plant-based therapies have been traditionally used in the region. This work reviews the studies conducted in Central America to assess the ability of extracts obtained from plants of local ethnomedical use to inhibit toxic activities of the venom of Bothrops asper, the snake responsible for approximately half of the snakebite envenomings in these countries. The search prioritized the description of the plants used in Guatemala, since most of the studies described in this work were conducted in that country, although references to other countries are included. Information concerning secondary metabolites and other pharmacological activities of these plant species, relevant to the treatment of snakebites, was also described. The literature search was conducted in the Google Scholar, PubMed and Scopus databases and completed with locally available literature. It was found that extracts of 12 plant species inhibited the hemorrhagic effect of the venom and three neutralized the edema-forming activity, while inhibition of proteolytic and phospholipase A2 (PLA2) activities was achieved by three and one plant species, respectively. Only Brownea rosa-de-monte was able to effectively counteract the in vitro coagulant effect of the venom. Some plant extracts screened in Guatemala demonstrated procoagulant or anti-thrombin intrinsic effects that might aggravate the coagulopathy induced by the venom. These findings underscore the need of carrying out scientific studies aimed to validate the inhibitory potential of Central American plant extracts and their metabolites against B. asper venom.

Pocos estudios científicos han explorado el uso de plantas medicinales para el tratamiento del envenenamiento ofídico en Centroamérica, a pesar de que las terapias basadas en plantas son de uso tradicional en la región. Este trabajo recopiló información sobre los estudios realizados en Centroamérica para evaluar la capacidad de extractos de plantas de uso etno-médico para inhibir las actividades tóxicas del veneno de Bothrops asper, la serpiente responsable de aproximadamente la mitad de los envenenamientos ofídicos en Centroamérica. La búsqueda priorizó la descripción de plantas utilizadas en Gua-temala, ya que la mayoría de los estudios aquí descritos fueron realizados en ese país. También se incluyó la descripción de los metabolitos secundarios y otras actividades farmacológicas de las especies evaluadas, que podrían explicar su uso como antiofídicos. La búsqueda de literatura se realizó en las bases de datos de Google Scholar, PubMed, Scopus, y se completó con literatura disponible localmente. Se determinó que 12 extractos de plantas inhibieron el efecto hemorrágico del veneno y tres el efecto edematígeno; la actividad proteolítica fue inhibida por extractos de tres especies y la fosfolipasa A2 (PLA2) por una especie. Solamente Brownea rosa-de-monte demostró inhibir efectivamente el efecto coagulante del veneno in vitro. Algunos extractos de las plantas tamizadas en Guatemala demostraron efectos procoagulantes o anti-trombina intrínsecos, que podrían agravar las alteraciones inducidas por el veneno en la coagulación. Estos hallazgos enfatizan la necesidad de validar el potencial de extractos de plantas centroamericanas y sus metabolitos secundarios para neutralizar el veneno de B. asper.

Changes in basement membrane components in an experimental model of skeletal muscle degeneration and regeneration induced by snake venom and myotoxic phospholipase A2.

Skeletal muscle regeneration is impaired after myonecrosis induced by viperid snake venoms, but the mechanisms behind such poor regenerative outcome are not fully understood. This study compared the changes in basement membrane (BM) components in mouse skeletal muscle in two different scenarios of muscle injury: (a) injection of Bothrops asper venom, as a model of poor regeneration, and (b) injection of a myotoxic fraction (Mtx) isolated from this venom, as a model of successful regeneration. The degradation and reposition of laminin, type IV collagen and fibronectin were assessed over time by a combination of immunohistochemistry, Western blot, and real time polymerase chain reaction. Both treatments induced degradation of laminin and type IV collagen in areas of muscle necrosis since day one, however, there were differences in the pattern of degradation and reposition of these proteins along time. Overall, Mtx induced a higher synthesis of fibronectin and higher degradation of laminin at intermediate time points, together with higher levels of transcripts for the chains of the three proteins. Instead, venom induced a higher degradation of laminin and type IV collagen at early time intervals, followed by a reduced recovery of type IV collagen by 15 days. These differences in extracellular matrix degradation and remodeling between the two models could be associated to the poor muscle regeneration after myonecrosis induced by B. asper venom.

Inhibición de las actividades proteolítica y fosfolipasa A2 del veneno de Bothrops asper por el extracto etanólico de Neurolaena lobata (L) Cass / Inhibition of proteolytic and phospholipase A2 activities of Bothrops asper venom by the ethanolic extract of Neurolaena lobata (L) Cass

Neurolaena lobata es utilizada tradicionalmente en Centroamérica para tratar la mordedura de serpiente, pero su efectividad para contrarrestar el envenenamiento producido por Bothrops asper ha sido poco estudiada. Se evaluó la capacidad del extracto etanólico de sus hojas para inhibir las actividades proteolítica, fosfolipasa A2 (PLA2; evaluada como hemólisis indirecta) y coagulante del veneno in vitro. El material vegetal fue colectado en Izabal, Guatemala, secado, se hicieron extracciones con etanol y se evaluó la presencia de actividades proteolítica, PLA2 y coagulante in-trínsecas en ensayos de concentración-actividad. Los efectos inhibitorios de la actividad proteolítica y PLA2 del veneno se evaluaron después de pre-incubar concentraciones variables del extracto con concentraciones fijas de veneno. La inhibición de la actividad coagulante del veneno no fue evaluada porque el extracto presentó actividad anticoagulante intrínseca dependiente de la concentración. El extracto inhibió completamente las actividades proteolítica (CE50 = 15.7 µg/µl) y PLA2 (CE50 = 32.5 µg/µl) del veneno. El análisis fitoquímico utilizando ensayos macro y semimicrométricos de cromatografía en capa fina, demostró la presencia de flavonoides, cumarinas, saponinas, taninos, sesquiterpenlactonas y aceites esenciales en el extracto. Su efecto sobre las proteínas del veneno se evaluó por electroforesis SDS-PAGE, mostrando cambios en el patrón electroforético atribuidos a la formación de complejos moleculares con los metabo-litos del extracto. Los resultados indican que el extracto podría inhibir los efectos tóxicos del veneno inducidos por las metaloproteinasas dependientes de zinc (SVMPs) y PLA2s, pero podría afectar las alteraciones en la coagulación, coadyuvando en la desfibrinogenación inducida por el veneno.

Neurolaena lobata has been used by traditional healers in Central America to treat snakebite, but its ability to neutralize Bothrops asper envenomations needs to be proved. This study evaluated the inhibitory potential of the ethanolic extract of the leaves of N. lobata against proteolytic, phospholipase A2 (PLA2) and coagulant activities of the venom in vitro. Leaves were collected in Izabal, Guatemala, dried, extracted with ethanol and concentration-response assays were conducted to detect intrinsic proteolytic, PLA2 (evaluated as indirect hemolysis) and coagulant activities. Assays for anti-proteolytic and anti-PLA2 activities were performed after pre-incubation of several amounts of extract with a fixed concentration of venom. Inhibition assay for the coagulant effect of the venom was not tested because pre-incubation of thrombin with the extract prolonged the clotting time of plasma in a concentration-dependent manner. Proteolytic (EC50 = 15.7 µg/µl) and PLA2 (EC50 = 32.5 µg/µl) activities of the venom resulted completely inhibited by the extract. Phytochemical profiles, determined by micrometric assays and semi microanalysis by thin layer chro-matography, showed the presence of flavonoids, coumarins, saponins, tannins, sesquiterpene lactones and essential oils in the extract. SDS-PAGE was used to assess the action of the extract on the venom proteins. Results showed changes in the electrophoretic profile, probably due to the formation of insoluble complexes with plant specialized metabolites. These findings demonstrated that the extract could be able to inhibit toxic effects triggered by zinc-dependent snake venom metalloproteinases (SVMPs) y PLA2s but might aggravate the alterations induced by the venom in coagulation.

Why is Skeletal Muscle Regeneration Impaired after Myonecrosis Induced by Viperid Snake Venoms?

Skeletal muscle regeneration after myonecrosis involves the activation, proliferation and fusion of myogenic cells, and a coordinated inflammatory response encompassing phagocytosis of necrotic cell debris, and the concerted synthesis of cytokines and growth factors. Myonecrosis often occurs in snakebite envenomings. In the case of venoms that cause myotoxicity without affecting the vasculature, such as those of many elapid snakes, regeneration proceeds successfully. In contrast, in envenomings by most viperid snakes, which affect the vasculature and extracellular matrix in addition to muscle fibers, regeneration is largely impaired and, therefore, the muscle mass is reduced and replaced by fibro-adipose tissue. This review discusses possible causes for such poor regenerative outcome including: (a) damage to muscle microvasculature, which causes tissue hypoxia and affects the inflammatory response and the timely removal of necrotic tissue; (b) damage to intramuscular nerves, which results in atrophy of regenerating fibers; (c) degradation of muscle cell basement membrane, compromising the spatial niche for proliferating myoblasts; (d) widespread degradation of the extracellular matrix; and (e) persistence of venom components in the damaged tissue, which may affect myogenic cells at critical points in the regenerative process. Understanding the causes of poor muscle regeneration may pave the way for the development of novel therapeutic interventions aimed at fostering the regenerative process in envenomed patients.

Inhibición de los efectos coagulante, fosfolipasa A2 y proteolítico del veneno de Bothrops asper por plantas usadas tradicionalmente en Centroamérica / Inhibition of the coagulant, phospholipase A2 and proteolytic effects of Bothrops asper venom by plants traditionally used in Central America

Existen pocos estudios científicos que demuestren el valor terapéutico de las plantas usadas en la medicina tradicional centroamericana para tratar el envenenamiento ofídico. En este estudio se evaluó la capacidad de los extractos etanólicos de nueve plantas de uso etnomédico en Centroamérica (Acacia hindsii, Aristolochia maxima, Bursera simaruba, Cissampelos pareira, Eryngium foetidum, Hamelia patens, Pimenta dioica, Piper peltatum y Sansevieria hyacinthoides) para inhibir el efecto coagulante del veneno de Bothrops asper. Tres de ellas (B. simaruba, E. foetidum y P. dioica) también fueron evaluadas en cuanto a su capacidad inhibitoria de los efectos fosfolipasa A2 (PLA2) y proteolítico del veneno. Las plantas fueron colectadas en Guatemala, secadas, extraídas con etanol y los efectos inhibitorios evaluados in vitro después de preincubar concentraciones variables de extracto con concentraciones fijas de veneno. Los resultados demostraron que ninguno de los extractos logró inhibir los efectos coagulante y PLA2, pero los extractos clorofilados de P. dioica y E. foetidum inhibieron efectivamente la actividad proteolítica del veneno. El tamizaje fitoquímico, mediante ensayos macro y semimicrométricos de cromatografía en capa fina, demostró la presencia de metabolitos secundarios reportados con actividad antiproteolítica (flavonoides, antocianinas, catequinas y taninos) en la composición química de los extractos de E. foetidum y P. dioica. Su efecto sobre el veneno se evaluó mediante electroforesis SDS-PAGE, demostrándose que no está mediado por degradación proteolítica de los componentes del veneno. El aislamiento y caracterización específica de sus metabolitos secundarios en futuros estudios, permitirá determinar el mecanismo de acción inhibitoria ejercido por estos extractos.

Medicinal plants have been traditionally used in Central America to treat snakebite envenomations, however, very few scientific studies aimed to demonstrate their efficacy and safety have been performed. In this study, ethanolic extracts of nine plants used in the region by traditional healers in snakebite cases (Acacia hindsii, Aristolochia maxima, Bursera simaruba, Cissampelos pareira, Eryngium foetidum, Hamelia patens, Pimenta dioica, Piper peltatum and Sansevieria hyacinthoides) were evaluated for their ability to inhibit the coagulant effect induced by the venom of the snake Bothrops asper. Three of these extracts (B. simaruba, E. foetidum and P. dioica) were also evaluated for their inhibitory effect on the phospholipase A2 (PLA2) and proteolytic activities of the venom. Plants were collected in Guatemala, dried, extracted with ethanol, and their inhibitory effects were evaluated in vitro after pre-incubation of several amounts of each extract with a challenge concentration of venom. Results showed that none of the extracts inhibited the coagulant and PLA2 effects; however, chlorophyllated extracts of E. foetidum and P. dioica effectively inhibited the proteolytic activity of the venom. Phytochemical analysis of these extracts, conducted by macrometric assays and semimicroanalysis by thin layer chromatography, identified secondary metabolites (flavones, anthocyanins, catequines and tannins) whose anti-proteolytic activities have been widely reported. SDS-PAGE analysis demonstrated that the mechanism of inhibition is not related to proteolytic degradation of the venom proteins by the plant extracts. Further studies are needed to isolate and identify the active venom inhibitory compounds of these plants, aimed to understand their mechanism of action.

Evaluación de la capacidad neutralizante de extractos de plantas de uso popular en Guatemala como antídotos para el envenenamiento por la mordedura de Bothrops asper / Neutralizing activities of ethanolic extracts of six plants traditionally used in Guatemala as antidotes for the envenomation caused by the snake Bothrops asper

Se determinó la capacidad de los extractos de seis plantas de uso etnomédico (Acacia hindsii, Aristolochia maxima, Cissampelos pareira, Hamelia patens, Piper peltatum y Sansevieria hyacinthoides) para neutralizar los efectos proteolítico y fosfolipasa A2 (PLA2) del veneno de Bothrops asper, la principal especie causante de envenenamiento en el país. Estos efectos, indicadores de la capacidad miotóxica, hemorrágica e inflamatoria del veneno, se evaluaron en ensayos controlados in vitro. Las plantas fueroncolectadas, secadas y extraídas por percolación con etanol. Los resultados demuestran que ninguno de los extractos posee actividad PLA2 o proteo-lítica intrínseca a las dosis estudiadas. Se determinó que tres de los extractos neutralizaron pobremente (< 50%) los efectos estudiados: S. hyacinthoides neutralizó 13.90 ± 6.41% del efecto PLA2 y P. peltatum y C. pareira el 32.98 ± 5.51% y 24.52 ± 7.45%, respectivamente, del efecto proteolítico. Por ello, ningún extracto se evaluó en pruebas de neutralización de la letalidad en ratones. Se concluye que no es recomendable el uso aislado de estas plantas en el tratamiento del envenenamiento por mordedura de B. asper, aunque posiblemente las que demostraron alguna actividad puedan resultar potenciadas al usarse en combinación con otras plantas, como se hace en las recetas tradicionales. Dada la complejidad de los componentes del veneno y sus efectos fisiopatológicos, falta investigar la capacidad de las plantas estudiadas para neutralizar las coagulopatías, edema y miotoxicidad producidas durante el envenenamiento.

Many plants are reported to be used in Guatemalan traditional medicine as antidotes against various effects of the snakebite; however, very few attempts have been made to evaluate their neutralizing capacity in controlled experiments. Six plants (Acacia hindsii, Cissampelos pareira; Hamelia patens, Piper peltatum, Sansevieria hyacinthoides and Aristolochia maxima) were evaluated in vitro for their ability to neutralize phospholipase A2 (PLA2) and proteolytic effects of the venom of Bothrops asper, the snake responsible for approximately half of the snakebite envenomations in Central America. These effects are indicatives of the ability of B. asper venom to produce myotoxicity, hemorrhage and inflammation. Plants were collected, dried and extracted by maceration with ethanol. After pre-incubation of several amounts of each extract with a challenge dose of venom, S. hyacinthoides demonstrated a low neutralizing capacity (< DE 50) of the PLA2 effect (13.90 ± 6.41%); C. pareira (32.98 ± 5.51%) and P. peltatum (24.52 ± 7.45%) neutralized less than 50% of the proteolytic effect. The results suggest that neither of the tested plants should be used individually to treat the main effects of B. asperenvenomation. However, the three low-active extracts might be potentiated when used in mixtures composed of several plants, as prepared by traditional healers. Given the complexity of the venom components and the multiple pathologic effects produced by B. asper envenomation, more tests are required to fully investigate the ability of this plants to neutralize the coagulant, fibrin(ogen)olytic, edematizing and myotoxic effects of the venom.

Homogenates of skeletal muscle injected with snake venom inhibit myogenic differentiation in cell culture.

INTRODUCTION: Viperid snakebite envenomings are characterized by muscle necrosis and a deficient regenerative response. METHODS: Homogenates from gastrocnemius muscles of mice injected with the venom of the snake Bothrops asper or with 2 tissue-damaging toxins were added to cultures of C2C12 myogenic cells. Myoblasts proliferation and fusion were assessed. Venom was detected by immunoassay in mouse muscle during the first week after injection. RESULTS: Homogenates from venom-injected muscle induced a drop in the number of proliferating myoblasts and a complete elimination of myotube formation. The inhibitory effect induced by homogenates from venom-injected mice was abrogated by preincubation of the homogenate with antivenom antibodies but not with control antibodies. This finding provides evidence that the effect is due to the action of venom in the tissue. CONCLUSIONS: Our observations suggest that traces of venom in muscle tissue might inhibit myotube formation and preclude a successful regenerative response.

Poor regenerative outcome after skeletal muscle necrosis induced by Bothrops asper venom: alterations in microvasculature and nerves.

BACKGROUND: Viperid snakebite envenoming is characterized by prominent local tissue damage, including muscle necrosis. A frequent outcome of such local pathology is deficient skeletal muscle regeneration, which causes muscle dysfunction, muscle loss and fibrosis, thus provoking permanent sequelae that greatly affect the quality of life of patients. The causes of such poor regenerative outcome of skeletal muscle after viperid snakebites are not fully understood. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: A murine model of muscle necrosis and regeneration was adapted to study the effects of the venom and isolated toxins of Bothrops asper, the medically most important snake in Central America. Gastrocnemius muscle was injected with either B. asper venom, a myotoxic phospholipase A(2) (Mtx), a hemorrhagic metalloproteinase (SVMP), or saline solution. At various time intervals, during one month, tissue samples were collected and analyzed by histology, and by immunocytochemical and immunohistochemical techniques aimed at detecting muscle fibers, collagen, endothelial cells, myoblasts, myotubes, macrophages, TUNEL-positive nuclei, and axons. A successful regenerative response was observed in muscle injected with Mtx, which induces myonecrosis but does not affect the microvasculature. In contrast, poor regeneration, with fibrosis and atrophic fibers, occurred when muscle was injected with venom or SVMP, both of which provoke necrosis, microvascular damage leading to hemorrhage, and poor axonal regeneration. CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: The deficient skeletal muscle regeneration after injection of B. asper venom is likely to depend on the widespread damage to the microvasculature, which affects the removal of necrotic debris by phagocytes, and the provision of nutrients and oxygen required for regeneration. In addition, deficient axonal regeneration is likely to contribute to the poor regenerative outcome in this model.

Increased infectivity of Staphylococcus aureus in an experimental model of snake venom-induced tissue damage.

Soft-tissue infection is commonly found in patients bitten by Latin American Bothrops snakes. Staphylococcus aureus, which is not present in the mouth of the snake, is frequently isolated from these infections. The effects of B. asper venom on infection with S. aureus were analyzed in a model of infection in envenomated mouse gastrocnemius muscle. Inoculation of 50 colony-forming units (cfu) of S. aureus was enough to cause infection in envenomated muscle, compared with >5x104 cfu without venom. This effect was also achieved by injection of venom myotoxin III (an A(2) phospholipase). A sarA mutant strain in which production of extracellular toxins and enzymes is up-regulated and binding of fibronectin, fibrinogen, and other host proteins is down-regulated was much less virulent than the corresponding parental strain, indicating that the ability of S. aureus to mask itself with host molecules might be more important than the effects of secreted toxins and enzymes in this kind of infection.

Membrane independent activation of fibroblast proMMP-2 by snake venom: novel roles for venom proteinases.

ProMMP-2 activation by Bothrops asper venom was investigated in mouse gastrocnemius muscle, mammalian cell culture and a cell-free system. Zymography revealed an increment of latent and activated forms of MMP-2 in muscle homogenates 1-3 days after venom injection. To clarify if venom can induce expression and activation of MMP-2, independently of the inflammatory response, venom was added to cultured human fibroblasts, endothelial and skeletal muscle cells, which expressed proMMP-2 constitutively. Venom activated proMMP-2 without promoting its expression. Venom also activated and degraded proMMP-2 in supernatants collected from fibroblast cultures, indicating that cells are not required for this activation. Pretreatment with EDTA increased MMP-2 activation and reduced degradation. Venom serine proteinases activated proMMP-2, whereas BaP1, a P-I metalloproteinase, predominantly degraded the latent and active forms of MMP-2. Moreover, pretreatment of conditioned medium with serine proteinase inhibitors greatly reduced the venom-induced activation, suggesting that venom proteinases activate MMP-2 via a serine proteinase secreted by fibroblasts. Venom also directly activated and degraded purified proMMP-2, albeit requiring a high concentration. Thus, B. asper venom proteinases activate and degrade proMMP-2 without inducing its synthesis. Serine proteinases play a dominant role in the activation, whereas metalloproteinases predominantly degrade MMP-2. Activation of proMMP-2 by snake venom proteinases, independently of the MT1-MMP/TIMP-2 pathway, extracellular matrix degradation or apoptosis, represents a novel mechanism in human fibroblasts.